In Platteville, Wisconsin, hall keeper Sylvie Fenn opens the glass case on fair morning and finds the pewter harvest cup gone. The case is whole. The latch is whole. Only three people hold a key. The reader already knows who took the cup, because the first chapter shows Homer Wick lifting it from its shelf, wrapping it in green cloth, and carrying it home in his coat pocket. The question is never who. The question is how Sylvie can prove it, one fact at a time, in a town where the suspect polished that cup for forty years and his mother polished it before him. A green thread in the latch. A photograph timed at eight forty-seven. A library sign-in at nine thirty-five. A round grey mark inside a coat pocket. One question only the taker could answer. When Homer finally speaks, the cup comes home whole, and the town must decide what keeping means, and what forgiving costs. A complete, standalone small-town novella of about 12254 words.